The Brent Honeywell Buzz

There isn’t a more intriguing pitching prospect in fantasy baseball than Brent Honeywell. Undrafted out of high school, he attended Walters State Community College in Tennessee, where his fastball velocity skyrocketed into the mid-90’s. As a result, so did his draft stock.

Armed with a fastball that sits in the 91-94 mph range, Honeywell can crank it up to 97 at times. What separates him from every other pitching prospect in baseball is that his best off-speed pitch is a screwball. Yes, you read that right, a screwball. We didn’t know it at the time, but the Tampa Bay Rays may have gotten the biggest steal of the entire 2014 MLB Draft when they selected Honeywell with the 72nd overall pick.

Prospect values can change drastically in a short period of time. Prime examples of this phenomenon would be the meteoric rises of Mookie Betts or Dalton Pompey from last season or Jose Fernandez from the low minors all the way to The Show the year prior. If we were to re-draft last years class right now, southpaw Carlos Rodon and catcher Kyle Schwarber would be the first two players off the board, not Brady Aiken and Tyler Kolek, who went first and second overall, respectively, back in June.

Prospect values change. Outside of Rodon and Schwarber, whose otherworldly professional debuts, and close proximity to the big leagues, have put them head and shoulders above the rest of the class, the pitcher who has generated more excitement, and seen his stock rise more than any other prospect from last year’s draft class is Honeywell, without question.

The screwball makes Honeywell an enigma, one that minor league hitters can’t seem to figure out. Honeywell defined his screwball to in a recent interview as “a left-handed curveball out od a right-handed arm slot,” which he used to flat-out dominate the Appalachian League in his professional debut last summer, posting a stellar 1.07 ERA with 40 strikeouts (10.7 K/9) and just six walks (1.6 BB/9) in 33 innings.

Nobody throws a screwball because nobody teaches it anymore. However there are a pair of notable exceptions. One of them is Honeywell’s father (also named Brent), who learned the pitch during his time in the minor leagues from a guy named Mike Marshall.

Yes, that Mike Marshall. He was the “one guy who scared the living hell” out of the Cincinnati Reds, wrote Joe Posnanski in “The Machine”. A screwball purveyor himself, Marshall won the National League Cy Young award in 1974, setting a Major League record with 106 appearances as a reliever. He pitching in 66 of 97 games before the All-Star break that year, earning the nickname “Iron Mike.”

“Pitchers have given it up,” Angels coach Don Baylor told the New York Times. “Coaches don’t even talk about it. It’s not in the equation.”

According to the same New York Times piece, which ran last summer, Fernando Valenzuela was essentially the last prominent starting pitcher to feature a screwball in his arsenal.

For a long period of time, nobody was teaching pitchers in the minors (or at the high school or collegiate level either) how to throw a screwball because it was commonly believed that the pitch would eventually hurt your arm. If Honeywell becomes an instant sensation, and has success at the Major League level with the pitch, you can bet that the screwball will make a comeback.

According FanGraphs, in the PITCHf/x era, which began in 2007, only four pitchers in the last 15 years have even thrown a screwball. Hector Santiago and Alfredo Simon are the lone major leaguers who still throw the pitch, and each used it less than one percent of the time last year. To put it in perspective, there are more knuckleballers in baseball than pitchers who know how to throw a screwball.

Honeywell doesn’t just throw a screwball; it’s his best off-speed pitch. It perfectly complements his mix of a fastball, curveball, and changeup. He also isn’t impressed by the one Santiago reportedly throws either.

“There was a New York Times story saying that somebody else (Santiago) threw a screwball in the big leagues,” said Honeywell to’s Jake Seiner. “No. Sorry dude. That’s not one.”

“That looks like my changeup,” Honeywell continued. “It’s a good pitch. It’s a great pitch. I’m not cutting him down or nothing. It’s a great changeup. But it’s not a screwball.”

Honeywell’s poignant comments in the piece are emblematic of the “confidence” and “swagger” that prospect evaluators rave about constantly in their write-ups. Craig Goldstein and Ben Carsley of Baseball Prospecuts defined Honeywell earlier this offseason as having “more swagger than me standing in front of the fridge in the middle of the night.” If you’ve ever heard that dynamic duo talk about sandwiches, you know that’s some serious swag.

In case you haven’t been paying attention, the Rays rotation is in shambles at the moment. Drew Smyly, Alex Cobb, Matt Moore and Alex Colome are all starting the season on the disabled list. Chris Archer and Jake Odorizzi headline the front of the rotation, but they are going to have to rely on a combination of Nate Karns, Matt Andriese, Mike Montgomery and Everett Teaford to fill out the rest of it. Yikes.

Honeywell’s odds of reaching the Majors anytime soon, as a starter at least, are extremely low, but I wouldn’t you rule it out completely if somehow the Rays were in the middle of a wild-card race late in the season. Like Kevin Garnett once said, “anything is possible.” Realistically, Honeywell is at least two years away, but by this time next year, he might be the best pitching prospect in the entire organization, depending on how you feel about Burch Smith, who missed most of last season in San Diego due to injury.

It’s hard not to get excited about a guy who throws a screwball and carries himself with more confidence than Ron Swanson in your local hardware store. It’s only a matter of time before Honeywell’s prospect stock rises to the point that he’s no longer a value in dynasty formats. The clock is ticking.

If “there is no such thing as a pitching prospect”, I’m going to throw caution to the wind, and gamble on a guy like Honeywell, who is so unlike every other pitching prospect in baseball and has a legitimate shot to make it to Tampa Bay within the next two years. If no current Major League hitters have ever even seen a screwball, what are the odds they can hit it right away? Once the screwball buzz hits the mainstream fantasy community, it will be too late to invest in Honeywell. The time is now to go after him in all dynasty formats. I’m all in.

George Bissell also writes for You can follow him on Twitter @GeorgeBissell

The Author

George Bissell

George Bissell


  1. Max
    March 25, 2015 at 11:33 am

    Do you prefer him or Duane Underwood? I also have Banuelos who I can cut to pick him up? Do you value him over Underwood or Banuelos more?

    • March 25, 2015 at 11:48 am

      Hey Max! I personally prefer Brent Honeywell over both of them long-term, but Duane Underwood took a huge step forward last season and with his mid-90’s velocity has a Major League future, no doubt. As far as Banuelos, he’s barely pitched the last two years due to elbow injuries and just doesn’t have the upside he once did. I would cut Banuelos for Honeywell based on long-term upside alone.

      • Max
        March 25, 2015 at 12:33 pm

        Thanks! Just recently picked Underwood up, I love his potential upside, so I cut Banuelos. What kind of realistic upside do you think Honeywell has?

  2. March 25, 2015 at 3:05 pm

    Honestly he’s so far away we really don’t know what his “upside” would be right now. The fastball is excellent, he has excellent command and a deep enough arsenal to remain a starter, the real x-factor is how the screwball plays in the upper minors. We won’t know his true upside until he gets to Double-A & Triple-A. If it’s truly un-hittable (like it was in the rookie-level Appy League) we could be looking at a future ace. His floor right now feels like a mid-rotation starter with the potential to be the Rays best pitcher within a few years.

  3. Mr. Dynasty
    March 25, 2015 at 3:14 pm

    Rank the following guys in order if they reach their ceiling. Steven Matz, Marcos Molina, Brent Honeywell, Reynaldo Lopez, Shohei Otani?

    • March 31, 2015 at 8:12 am

      I don’t think you can compare “ceilings” with these guys because they are all at different stages in their development process. It’s a gripe I have with the terminology more than anything else. You have to be realistic about a players odds of reaching their “ceiling”.

      The two I prefer personally are Matz and Honeywell. Bret has compared Matz to “what Jon Niese should be” and I agree with that assessment. He’s not a front of the rotation guy so he doesn’t have the highest ceiling, but I would give him the best odds of actually producing in the Majors right now. In less than two years, Honeywell could either be the best pitcher in Tampa Bay or a fringe fifth starter type depending on how his stuff plays in the upper minors. The range of outcomes is that wide. Sure he has a higher ceiling, but I would bet on Matz if I had to pick a guy right now because he’s so close and we have a good idea of how he will perform right away.

  4. […] of it as any fantasy prospect evaluator in the Twitter-era. I’ll admit it. Earlier this week, I wrote a glowing profile on Tampa Bay Rays right-handed pitching prospect Brent Honeywell, whose unique screwball and […]

  5. May 22, 2015 at 11:07 am

    […] Brent Honeywell. The 20-year-old screwballer looks flat-out dominated at Low-A this spring and looks like the next big thing to come out of the Rays system. Middle-of-the-rotation starters like Snell are the riskiest propositions and most fungible assets, […]

Previous post

Cheap Speed with Odubel Herrera

Next post

Going Deep: Recap of a 20 Team Dynasty MiLB Draft (Picks 21-30)