Dynasty BaseballWhat To Do About...

Fresh Takes: Hold Steady on Chris Archer

As The Hold Steady so aptly state in Slapped Actress: “Don’t mention Tampa, they’ll just know all the rest”

Something something #raystank. Something something no fans. Something something the Trop sucks.

Yawn. Being a Rays fan means having to catch crap from most of the baseball world. It gets old. That being said, when the team is 3-11 it’s hard to mount an effective comeback aside from “yeah well It’s probably snowing where you are and it’s not here.” Chris Archer used to be a bright spot in being a Rays fan, but his start to the season may have some second-guessing that. Well, I’m here to tell you not to worry, because there’s nothing to indicate a serious change or cause for concern.

There’s been plenty of digital ink spilled on Archer, but to sum him up: 29 years old, k/9 of over 10 since 2015, ERA always higher than his FIP and xFIP. It’s been particularly bad in 2018, though- 7.84 ERA through four starts while his xFIP is 3.8.  So let’s take a deeper-ish look at some factors that may be affecting that ERA. Granted, we’re only talking about 20 innings, but we need to try and figure something out so we know whether to buy or sell.

2017 11.15 2.69 1.21 .325 71.3 14.1
2018 10.45 3.92 1.74 .379 55.9 18.2

Ok, so strikeouts per nine are down, walks and homers per nine are up. Groundball rate is a bit down and home run to fly ball is a bit up. His BABIP is crazy high and his strand rate is crazy low, so early returns indicate that he’s a little unlucky (his career BABIP is .297, and career strandrate is 72.1%). BABIP and strandrate more inline with his career numbers will correlate to a lower ERA.

Next step- let’s see if we can get any information from his pitch usage and effectiveness.

2017 47.6 95.8 -0.22 8.0 86.2 -1.15 44.5 89.1 1.11
2018 45.7 94.8 -3.82 6.4 87.2 -0.79 47.9 88.5 -0.06

No big revelations here, especially given the small sample size we’re working with. His usage, velocity, and effectiveness for the fastball, changeup, and slider (respectively) aren’t indicating anything concerning.

Let’s take a look at some charts to see if there’s anything else we’re missing, all courtesy of Brooks Baseball.

Overall profile, 2017 v. 2018

Whiff Profiles, 2017 v. 2018

and Swinging Profiles, 2017 v. 2018

nooooooope. No big differences between 2017 and what’s come in 2018 so far.

So there’s no change from 2017 to 2018, but maybe there’s something in lefties v. righties this year? (h/t to Adam Lawler for suggesting I take a look)



bingo. Archer is getting knocked around by lefties- .439/.511/.825 versus .178/.245/.311 from righties. His career numbers (.241/.312/.395 for lefites v. .226/.288/.348 for righties) tell me that this is not a long-term issue and represents a buying opportunity from panicky owners.

While the small 2018 sample size can’t really tell us anything to begin with, I wanted to take a look for anything that could be concerning if it continued into a more substantial sample size. Yes, he’s getting hit by lefties, but there’s no big change in anything else that would explain why. Armed with this knowledge, I’m trying to buy Archer everywhere I don’t have him, hoping that his current owner is scared of his slow start. And in the leagues I’ve already got him, I’m holding steady.

The Author

Ian Hudson

Ian Hudson

Ian is an editor for The Dynasty Guru and a bowtie enthusiast. If you guessed one of those things about him you could probably guess the other.

He's also an attorney in Tampa, Florida.

Go Rays.

1 Comment

  1. […] warns dynasty/keeper league owners not to overreact to the bad start for Chris […]

Previous post


Next post

The Dynasty Guru's Triple Play: The New York Mets!