2018 Dynasty Baseball RankingsDynasty BaseballDynasty Prospect Rankings

Upon Further Review: Notable Grade Changes

The prospect positional rankings series is complete! The schedule (located at the bottom) contains links to each article in the series. Since the rankings process began in November, fall/winter league performance and further research have forced reassessment of grades. As such, the following prospects experienced notable grade changes, positive and negative, significantly impacting positional ranking.

The prospect rankings schedule and a guide to fantasy tool grades can be found here. In addition, to see where the prospects below now fall in the overall rankings, you can obtain access to the updated Top 600 Dynasty League Players with a small donation.

Positive Grade Changes

Peter Alonso, 1B, New York Mets

Prior Grades: 50 hit, 65 power, 0 speed, 40 risk

Present Grades: 50 hit, 65 power, 0 speed, 45 risk

Arguably, Peter Alonso is the premier power bat in minors. With plus bat speed and 80-grade raw power, he generates unique, majestic blasts, such as the one below. Further, Alonso has a mature, patient approach at the plate with very reasonable swing-and-miss (9.5% swinging strikes), allowing projection on his hit tool to average (or even above). Most importantly, he likely will assume the starting first base job for the Mets by mid-April. As such, risk associated with a 24-year-old R/R first base prospect is less than normal. Alonso is a top-10 dynasty option at first base and a top-15 fantasy prospect.

Evan White, 1B, Seattle Mariners

Prior Grades: 55 hit, 45 power, 0 speed, 40 risk

Present Grades: 55 hit, 50 power, 0 speed*, 40 risk

A reported swing change presumably contributed to Evan White’s explosive final 27 games (.379/.467/.689). In addition, observers report significant pull-side power and big exit velocities. Meanwhile, although he is a plus runner underway, he is slow to accelerate, and, likely as a result, finds little success stealing bases (23-for-33 in 297 total games between college and the minors). White possesses untapped fantasy potential, with the ability to provide rare, five-category value at first base. Should his swing change continue to pay dividends, he is a potential riser in 2019.

Willians Astudillo, C/3B, Minnesota Twins 

Prior Grades: 55 hit, 40 power, 0 speed, 45 risk

Present Grades: 60 hit, 40 power, 0 speed, 45 risk

Willians Astudillo has developed a cult following among fantasy baseball writers. It may be due to his all-out hustle, and statement, “I just wanted to show that chubby people also run.”

It may be his fun-loving attitude.

It may be his most recent epic performance in the Venezuela Winter League (.325/.370/.500 with 10 home runs and 4-to-13 strikeout-to-walk ratio) including the below home run. With all that said, Astudillo still faces an uphill battle for playing time, competing with Jason Castro and Mitch Garver behind the plate. There remains substantial risk the novelty of his contact-heavy approach wears off fast. Nevertheless, the catcher landscape is barren, and he provides enough upside to target as a borderline, top-20 dynasty catcher and a top-10 catcher in redraft leagues.

A pun, courtesy of Jordan Rosenblum: what type of apartment does Willians live in?

A studio!

Others of Note:

  • Jesus Sanchez, OF, Tampa Bay Rays (risk reduces from 40 to 45)
  • Luis Garcia, 2B/3B/SS, Washington Nationals (power increases from 40 to 45)
  • Antonio Cabello, OF, New York Yankees (speed bonus increases from 5 to 10)
  • George Valera, OF, Cleveland Indians (power increases from 50 to 55)
  • Nico Hoerner, SS, Chicago Cubs (power increases from 40 to 45)
  • Tyler Nevin, 1B/3B, Colorado Rockies (power increases from 45 to 50)

Negative Grade Changes

Alex Reyes, RHP, St. Louis Cardinals

Prior Grades: 65 repertoire, 45 command and control, 5 depth, 45 risk

Present Grades: 65 repertoire, 45 command and control, 5 depth, 40 risk

Alex Reyes should carve out a sizable role for the Cardinals this year. Unfortunately, it is unclear what role that will be. His value will take a hit if the Cardinals relegate him to a non-closing, late-inning role. With a wealth of options for the rotation and, now, the bullpen (signing of Andrew Miller), Reyes enters the year (and the foreseeable future) with too much uncertainty.

Michael Chavis, 3B, Boston Red Sox

Prior Grades: 45 hit, 60 power, 0 speed, 45 risk

Present Grades: 45 hit, 60 power, 0 speed, 40 risk

In fantasy, fielding is only relevant to the extent it facilitates or hinders opportunity and eligibility. In the case of Michael Chavis, it is highly relevant. Simply put, he is a poor defender. Few observers believe he will be anything more than a borderline-average defender at third base. Given his size (5’10”), he also lacks the length to play first base. A prospect without a position is problematic. In the short-term, Chavis likely has no place on the competitive Red Sox active roster.

Kyler Murray, OF (or QB), Oakland Athletics

Prior Grades: 50 hit, 50 power, 10 speed, 35 risk

Present Grades: 50 hit, 50 power, 10 speed, 30 risk

Last Monday, Kyler Murray declared for the NFL Draft. His decision has devolved into a battle of the major sports. In fact, he has been working out with superstar Antonio Brown (below). Will Murray choose football or baseball? The better question as a fantasy owner, however, is, do you want to draft him in a FYPD to find out?

Others of Note:

  • Ryan Mountcastle, 3B, Baltimore Orioles (hit decreases from 55 to 50)
  • DJ Peters, OF, Los Angeles Dodgers (power decreases from 65 to 60)
  • Will Smith, C/3B, Los Angeles Dodgers (power decreases from 55 to 50)
  • Jordan Groshans, SS, Toronto Blue Jays (hit decreases from 55 to 50)
  • Nick Gordon, SS/2B, Minnesota Twins (power decreases from 45 to 40)
  • Hudson Potts, 3B, San Diego Padres (power decreases from 55 to 50)

Jesse Roche's 2019 Prospect Series

11/5/18Top 600 Dynasty League Players, Fall Preview
11/12/182019 Top 40 Fantasy Catcher Prospects
11/19/182019 Top 30 Fantasy First Base Prospects
11/26/182019 Top 30 Fantasy Second Base Prospects
12/3/182019 Top 40 Fantasy Third Base Prospects
12/10/182019 Top 70 Fantasy Shortstop Prospects, Part 1
12/17/182019 Top 70 Fantasy Shortstop Prospects, Part 2
12/24/182019 Top 140 Fantasy Outfield Prospects, Part 1
12/31/182019 Top 140 Fantasy Outfield Prospects, Part 2
1/7/192019 Top 210 Fantasy Pitching Prospects, Part 1
1/16/192019 Top 210 Fantasy Pitching Prospects, Part 2
1/21/19Upon Further Review: Notable Grade Changes
1/28/192019 Top 500 Fantasy Prospects
2/11/192019 Top 100 Upside-Only Fantasy Prospects
2/20/192019 First Year Player Draft Rankings
3/11/192019 Impact Prospects
3/18/192019 Breakout Prospects
4/1/19Prospects Breaking Camp
4/3/19Monthly Prospect Update: Infielders, March 2019
4/4/19Monthly Prospect Update: Outfielders, March 2019
4/5/19Monthly Prospect Update: Pitchers, March 2019
4/22/19Scouting Report: Grayson Rodriguez
4/29/19Scouting Reports: Delmarva & Greensboro
5/2/19Monthly Prospect Update: Infielders, April 2019
5/4/19Monthly Prospect Update: Outfielders, April 2019
5/8/19Monthly Prospect Update: Pitchers, April 2019
5/10/19Top 200 Fantasy Prospects, May 2019
5/27/192019 MLB Draft: Top Fantasy Prospects
6/3/192019 MLB Draft Live Observations
6/5/19Monthly Prospect Update: Infielders, May 2019
6/6/19Monthly Prospect Update: Outfielders, May 2019
6/7/19Monthly Prospect Update: Pitchers, May 2019
6/10/19Top 200 Fantasy Prospects, June 2019
6/17/192019 Short Season Assignments: DSL, PIO, NWL & NYP
6/24/192019 Short Season Assignments: AZL, GCL & APP
7/1/19Monthly Prospect Update: Infielders, June 2019
7/3/19Monthly Prospect Update: Outfielders, June 2019
7/5/19Monthly Prospect Update: Pitchers, June 2019
7/8/192019/2020 First Year Player Draft, Rounds 1-2
7/12/19Top 600 Dynasty League Players, July 2019
7/15/192019/2020 First Year Player Draft, Rounds 3-4
7/22/192019/2020 First Year Player Draft, Rounds 5-6
7/29/19Short Season Breakout Prospects
8/7/19Monthly Prospect Update: Infielders, July 2019
8/8/19Monthly Prospect Update: Outfielders, July 2019
8/9/19Monthly Prospect Update: Pitchers, July 2019
8/12/19Top 200 Fantasy Prospects, August 2019
8/19/19Scouting Report: Seth Corry
9/11/19Monthly Prospect Update: Infielders, August 2019
9/13/19Monthly Prospect Update: Outfielders, August 2019
10/4/19Top 200 Fantasy Prospects, September 2019

Please feel free to post comments, questions, or your own observations!

Next up, the 2019 Top 500 Fantasy Prospects. Stay tuned!

Follow me on Twitter @jaroche6

The Author

Jesse Roche

Jesse Roche

Jesse is an attorney, currently residing in Greensboro. An avid fantasy baseball player, Jesse has experience in a diverse range of leagues, including head-to-head, rotisserie, points, and simulation. Jesse is a five-time website-wide champion at Benchwarmer Baseball and a repeat champion of a dynasty league with John Sickels at Minor League Ball. With a specific interest in baseball prospects, Jesse plans to provide in-depth analysis of up-and-coming stars accessible to all league sizes and types.

Previous post

The Dynasty Guru's Top 50 Third Basemen, #1-20

Next post

The Dynasty Guru’s Top 50 Third Basemen, #21-50