Up the Middle: Jurickson Profar

Happy Thanksgiving! I’m sure all of us can think of at least one small thing that we can be grateful for today. For me, this month brought the birth of my second child, a baby girl, and gratitude is definitely one of the many strong emotions that comes with being a new parent. On the baseball front, the Rangers made a major play to free up their logjam in the middle infield by trading Ian Kinsler to the Detroit Tigers. Since I own Jurickson Profar in a dynasty league, I couldn’t help but feel all warm and tingly inside when I heard the news. After bouncing around the Texas infield last year, I’d imagine Profar is more than grateful for the opportunity to show what he can do with everyday at bats in 2014. But will he suddenly put it all together in 2014 and live up to the massive hype that surrounded him prior to the 2013 season? I’m not so sure…

Personally, I landed Profar in a deadline deal with a contender halfway through the 2013 season. It was a good deal for both of us. The contender needed to part with Profar’s inconsistent playing time and low counting stats, while I was in a semi rebuilding mode and looked at Profar as a player I could build around. But I’m not going to get all in a tizzy about this recent Kinsler trade and start counting my Profar chickens before they hatch, thinking that playing time was Profar’s only roadblock to greatness. Fantasy baseball, especially dynasty league fantasy baseball, takes a lot of patience. I don’t expect anything particularly extraordinary from my shiny new toy in 2014, despite the fact that he is probably one of the most talented young players out there. Mike Newman, a fantasy writer whom I respect a great deal, said it best in a recent Rotoscouting newsletter:

“My guess is he’ll hit in the seven, eight or nine hole in 2014. The bottom of the order is pretty weak in Texas, so I worry his run and RBI totals will wind up in the 55-65 range over the course of a full season. 2014 might be an opportunity to scoop him up from an impatient owner at some point. Don’t expect a breakout campaign until 2015 at the earliest.”

This was a refreshing viewpoint and a nice reality check for guys like me who were chomping at the bit to see Profar play every day. It’s also a great reminder that even dynasty league owners can get a little impatient. After a 2013 season in which he produced 6 homers, 2 stolen bases, and a .234 average in a little over 300 PA, Profar owners may not be in the mood for another “disappointing” season. In other words, even a top prospect talent like Profar has to be looked at as part of a dynasty team’s long term plan rather than short term solution.

Prospect letdown can be a bitch, so let’s try to remember the glowing reports from scouts on his hit tool and makeup before getting our undies in a knot. He is only 21 after all, and while he struggled against lefties in 2013, he did manage to keep his strikeout percentage south of 20% and his line drive percentage north of 23%. There’s no reason to believe he isn’t who we thought he was, it just might not all come to fruition in the next calendar year despite a significant boost in playing time. It’s hard to be patient when you’re sitting on one of the better young talents in the game, but that’s exactly what I’ll have to be –  patient.

Somebody told me that happiness isn’t always about getting what you want when you want it. It’s about being grateful for what you have while you have it. I’m going to enjoy watching Profar play this year and I’m thrilled to own him in a dynasty league, even if his numbers aren’t going to carry my middle infield right away. I’d recommend others do the same, and look to acquire him from impatient owners who aren’t willing to endure growing pains.

Mike also writes for Razzball. You can follow him on the Twitter @643ball

The Author




  1. Don
    December 8, 2013 at 5:10 pm

    I just traded Profar for Buxton in my 10 team, 10 keeper league that is position specific (must start someone at each actual position). I have Segura and Machado (if he ever moves) and there just aren’t a lot of quality CF’s out there. Plus with Correa and Baez sitting out there I feel like SS is actually deeper than CF. Give me the truth, am I an idiot?

    • December 8, 2013 at 7:51 pm

      Thanks for reading Don…I don’t think you are an idiot at all… Buxton is just as highly regarded a prospect as Profar was and if you have those other options at middle infield you are in great shape. Correa and Baez are both great options down the road as well, Can you scoop one of them up to stash on like a farm system or something? I’d be jumping on Correa if you can… Your team sounds a lot like mine…I have Machado and Segura in the majors and Buxton and Correa on my farm. The fact that guys move off of the shortstop position makes me want to “stock up” on them, but it doesn’t sound like a super deep league with only ten keepers, so you should be golden. 😀

      • Don
        December 9, 2013 at 8:02 pm

        Hi Mike,

        Thanks for the insight. As I mentioned its a 10 team 10 keeper league and I actually snagged Baez for my roster even though he won’t be one of my 10 keepers. I will probably snag one of them after our draft and just stash him and then keep him next year. I usually keep 1 stud prospect who I know may not contribute the following year; that’s actually what I did with Profar. I really appreciate you taking the time to reply and look forward to future articles.


  2. December 9, 2013 at 9:11 pm

    @Don: anytime 😀

  3. December 12, 2013 at 3:36 pm

    Congrats on the baby girl!
    Thanks for the recap on Profar… Luckily I have him in my farm system heading into 2014, but unless he gets fewer than 133 AB this season, I’ll need to promote him for 2015… So I’m raising a toast and hoping he puts up a top 12 fantasy 2b season so I can get some positive value from him in 2014…

    • December 12, 2013 at 4:43 pm

      Thanks Robert! Top 12 is definitely possible given the position. That’s a nice situation you have him in and, as Newman pointed out above, 2015 could be the real breakout. Thanks for reading!

Previous post

Digging for Diamonds: Infield BABIP Outliers

Next post

Shuffling the Deck: Post-Prospects in the AL Central