Dynasty DynamicsUncategorized

Rebuilding a Dynasty League Roster, Part 6: The Re-Evaluation Stage

I mentioned at the end of the previous post that we were finally at the end of “Stage 1” once the initial trades/free agent moves were completed.  Well, Stage 2 starts right now – and to be perfectly honest, it’s much less romantic and spastic than Stage 1. However, it’s just as important. What we have set to accomplish up until this point is building up the team’s assets from a more general perspective, and now we have to get a little more specific. We have to determine what we’re going to need between now and the beginning of our time horizon in order to be a contending team.

The first step of this is to recreate the exercise we did in Step 3 of this series and re-examine the team at the time horizon of contention after the initial roster moves have been made. To refresh your memory, we’re going to look at a full active roster and bench, plus any potential top-50 prospects (read: future trade chips). Here’s my best case scenario roster, coupled with a descriptor based on expected performance in that season versus the average 16-team league starter (weak, average, strong, elite):

C – Matt Wieters (strong)

1B – Albert Pujols (elite)

2B – Chase Utley (average)

SS – Yunel Escobar (weak)

3B – Kevin Youkilis (average)

OF – Oscar Taveras (strong), Alex Rios (strong), Jayson Werth (average)

Util – Travis d’Arnaud (average), Yonder Alonso (average)

P – Brandon Morrow (strong), Lance Lynn (strong), Brett Anderson (strong), Danny Duffy (average), Casey Kelly (average), Ryan Madson (average), David Robertson (average)

BN – Jemile Weeks (average), Jedd Gyorko (average), Brett Jackson (average), Matt Davidson (weak), Zach Britton (average), Carlos Martinez (average), John Lamb (weak), Kyle Gibson (weak)

Potential Top 50 Prospects – George Springer, Blake Swihart, Alen Hanson, Jose Campos, Taylor Guerrieri, Aaron Sanchez

The biggest difference between this list and the previous one is the most obvious – I’ve gone from one potential top-50 prospect to six. Plus, I’ve done that while also improving the number of “strong” players from four to six and decreasing the number of “weak” players from six to four. But this is only the quantitative view of what’s in front of me; let’s take a look from a qualitative perspective.

The most glaring weakness that this team has positionally is SS, as Escobar is a pretty uninspiring option at the major league level and I don’t have anyone at the position that can overtake him before then. Beyond that, I’m not particularly strong at 2B, 3B or OF – but at least I have options there. Upper-level prospects like Oscar Taveras, Jedd Gyorko, Brett Jackson and Matt Davidson combined with current fort-holders like Utley, Youkilis, Jemile Weeks, Rios and Werth should provide me with enough options to piece together decent performance from those spots.

On the pitching side, I definitely have a higher quantity of potential contributing arms after my initial flurry of moves. But, the only problem with predicting pitching is that you can’t – you just have to get as much talent as you can and hope for the best, both from a development and health perspective. In my case, I have my five pitchers currently recovering from Tommy John surgery as of the end of June and Zach Britton who is a bit of a wild card after missing the first three months of this season with a shoulder injury.

But in the end, all I’m trying to figure out from this stage of the rebuild process is if there are particular areas I need to focus on positionally. Fortunately for me, it’s a points league and I don’t have to think about category positioning. When dealing with rotisserie leagues, Phase 2 is the beginning of the time when you should start thinking about how balanced you are across categories – you shouldn’t worry about it before then. It’s obvious by now that I’m probably going to need to deal for a shortstop. I’m also likely to need a few more pitchers. But on the bright side, I have good catching depth, which I will be looking to leverage in order to build up the rest of my roster. Outside of those two specific need areas, I’m just going to be on the lookout for the best available players as we move into the next step: acquiring my secondary targets.

Rebuilding a Dynasty League Roster, Part 1: Setting the Table
Rebuilding a Dynasty League Roster, Part 2: Establishing Your Time Horizon
Rebuilding a Dynasty League Roster, Part 3: The Evaluation Stage
Rebuilding a Dynasty League Roster, Part 4: The Opening Trades
Rebuilding a Dynasty League Roster, Part 4a: Wait at Your Own Peril
Rebuilding a Dynasty League Roster, Part 5: The Free Agents

The Author

The Dynasty Guru

The Dynasty Guru


  1. Derek
    October 2, 2012 at 1:53 am

    Fortunately for me, it’s a points league and I don’t have to think about category positioning. When dealing with rotisserie leagues, Phase 2 is the beginning of the time when you should start thinking about how balanced you are across categories – you shouldn’t worry about it before then.

    Just wondering what you would advise with a H2H league. I am new to H2H and currently at this stage. Wondering if I should go my normal roto team-building route and target HR/K’s or try something different, like focusing on acquiring categories that are more readily available and/or think about a punting strategy.


    • October 2, 2012 at 2:39 am

      In a H2H league, I always try to mold my strategy to my team rather than trying to do it the other way. So if I don’t have any good steals guys, maybe I won’t worry about that category — but I would consider that much later on for a H2H league than for a rotisserie. Of course, that’s assuming it’s not so heavily loaded in certain categories.

  2. October 4, 2012 at 6:31 pm

    I am really enjoying the articles in this series. I hope you keep posting more in the off-season to make the winter more enjoyable.

    More people should participate in dynasty leagues because they are so much more in-depth than traditional re-draft leagues.

    • October 4, 2012 at 6:41 pm

      Thanks – I appreciate that. There are many more parts to this series and much more content on top of that coming this off-season, including a full set of dynasty league rankings that you won’t find anywhere else.

  3. Rich
    October 23, 2012 at 5:34 am

    I’m really interested to see what you do at SS, I am stuck with Escobar too. I thought I had Nick Franklin waiting in the wings, but looks like he will project at 2B instead (got Wong too). Taveras and D’Arnaud are two guys I targeted and dealt for along with Taijuan Walker, so hopefully I am on the right track. Keep up the good work, good stuff..

    • October 23, 2012 at 2:37 pm

      Thanks for the kind words. I’m curious as to what happens at SS long-term with my team as well. I’ve been in the market for a SS, but haven’t come across the right move for my team yet. I still have time to sort it out before making a move that I’m not sold on. Plus, in a deep points league, Escobar is at least slightly above replacement level — in my league he was less than 10 points from being a top-16 SS.

      With all that said, if you accumulate as much value and talent in other positions, those sort if positional deficiencies will work themselves out over time. And with three guys like that in tow for you, it sounds like you’re on the right path. Good luck!

      • Rich
        October 25, 2012 at 4:55 am

        Escobar has always been bad in even years, good in odd years, so maybe he will bounce back next year. I wish I had your catcher depth, Wieters should get you a solid return if you are sold on D’Arnaud and go that route. Also, I’m with you on Brett Anderson. I think he is still a future ace if healthy and dealt for him in my rebuilding process this past year. Also, are you still as high on Lance Lynn? I am debating myself whether or not this would be a good time for me to try and buy low on him after his somewhat disappointing finish.

        • October 25, 2012 at 1:32 pm

          I am still high on Lance Lynn. I wouldn’t hold his post-season performance against him, as seems like it could be fatigue related. When he’s gone out there, he’s been dominant for a couple of innings then fallen apart — and it hasn’t changed my projections for him in 2013 and beyond.

Previous post

Using Minor League Stats to Your Advantage: What’s Your Baseline?

Next post

A Few Last Minute Pick-ups in Keeper/Dynasty Leagues, Part 1 (The Hitters)